Home / Blog / Marketing

Quick Review Journals in Marketing for PhD Students

Quick Review Journals in Marketing for PhD Students (Marketingly)

A PhD in marketing runs on deadlines. Job market papers, progress reviews and funding renewals all go better when a manuscript has a decision behind it, so the speed of a journal matters almost as much as its reputation. The good news is that many marketing and consumer research journals now publish their own review times. The list below uses those figures to show where a first decision comes quickly and where a full review round is short.

How we picked these journals #

We only kept journals that publish their speed on their own site or publisher page, and we took every figure from that page. Each journal had to publish in marketing or consumer research and report either a fast first decision or a short review round. The order is our own, guided mainly by the length of the review round and then by the time to a first decision, since the review round is the wait most students feel. SAGE reports a median peer review duration, Elsevier reports the time from submission to a decision after review, and Taylor & Francis reports the average days to a first post-review decision, so the figures are close cousins but not identical. One caution applies to every journal here. A first decision of one to five days is almost always a desk decision, which means the editor read the paper and decided without sending it to reviewers. Fast first decisions tell you how quickly you will learn whether a paper is in scope, and the review round tells you how long the real wait is.

1. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services #

Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services is an Elsevier journal on retail, services and consumer behavior, with a steady stream of work on e-commerce, live streaming and online reviews. Elsevier lists a median of 1 day to first decision and 20 days from submission to a decision after review. Publishing is free on the subscription route, and the open access option carries an APC of USD 4,890.

2. Digital Enterprise Studies #

Digital Enterprise Studies is a quarterly, open access business journal covering consumer trust, privacy and adoption in digital markets, along with firm conduct in pricing and advertising. It reports 3 to 4 weeks to a first decision under double-anonymous review. There are no fees for authors or readers.

3. Journal of Promotion Management #

The Journal of Promotion Management is a Taylor & Francis title on advertising, sales promotion, public relations and integrated communication. Its page lists 1 day on average to a first decision and 34 days to a first post-review decision. Authors can publish at no cost through the subscription route or pay an APC for open access.

4. Journal of International Consumer Marketing #

The Journal of International Consumer Marketing publishes consumer research that crosses national and cultural borders. Taylor & Francis reports 2 days on average to a first decision and 40 days to a first post-review decision. It suits PhD projects that compare consumers across countries or test whether a known effect holds in a new market.

5. Journal of Global Marketing #

The Journal of Global Marketing covers international marketing strategy, branding and consumer behavior across markets. The publisher lists 4 days to a first decision and 46 days to a first post-review decision. Like the other Taylor & Francis titles here, it is hybrid, so the subscription route is free.

6. Journal of Macromarketing #

The Journal of Macromarketing studies how markets and marketing affect society, from sustainability to consumer welfare. SAGE reports a median of 1 day to first decision and 58 days of peer review. Its acceptance rate is listed at 10.9 percent, so the speed comes with real selectivity.

7. Journal of Marketing #

The Journal of Marketing is the flagship journal of the American Marketing Association and one of the most cited outlets in the field. SAGE lists a median of 4 days to first decision and 59 days for the peer review round. The acceptance rate is 7.3 percent, which means most of those four-day decisions are desk rejections.

8. Industrial Marketing Management #

Industrial Marketing Management publishes business to business marketing, sales and channel research. Elsevier reports 3 days to a first decision and 62 days to a decision after review. Publishing through the subscription route costs nothing, and the open access APC is USD 4,520.

9. Journal of Public Policy & Marketing #

The Journal of Public Policy & Marketing is the natural home for work on regulation, privacy, consumer protection and marketing in the public interest. SAGE gives a median of 3 days to first decision and 63 days of peer review. Its acceptance rate of 15.8 percent is the highest among the AMA journals on this list.

10. Journal of International Marketing #

The Journal of International Marketing is the AMA journal for global marketing strategy and cross-border consumer research. SAGE reports a median of 4 days to a first decision and 69 days of peer review. With an acceptance rate of 4.8 percent, it rewards a paper that is clearly in scope before it is sent.

11. International Journal of Research in Marketing #

The International Journal of Research in Marketing is the journal of the European Marketing Academy and publishes quantitative and behavioral marketing research. Elsevier lists 8 days to a first decision and 70 days to a decision after review. The subscription route is free, and the open access APC is USD 4,260.

12. Journal of Marketing Research #

The Journal of Marketing Research is a leading outlet for pricing, advertising, choice modeling and field experiments. SAGE reports a median of 5 days to first decision and 75 days for peer review. Its acceptance rate is 5.9 percent, so treat the fast first decision as an early read on fit.

13. Journal of Marketing Management #

The Journal of Marketing Management is a broad journal that takes quantitative, qualitative and critical marketing research. Taylor & Francis lists 8 days to a first decision and 75 days to a first post-review decision. The page also lists an 11 percent acceptance rate.

14. Journal of Consumer Psychology #

The Journal of Consumer Psychology is the journal of the Society for Consumer Psychology and publishes experimental work on judgment, choice and persuasion. Wiley reports a median of 16 days from submission to first decision, and it does not publish a separate review round figure. The listed acceptance rate is 4 percent, which places it at the selective end of this list.

Side by side #

Journal First decision Review round Fee
Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 1 day 20 days Free via subscription
Digital Enterprise Studies 3 to 4 weeks Not published Free
Journal of Promotion Management 1 day 34 days Free via subscription
Journal of International Consumer Marketing 2 days 40 days Free via subscription
Journal of Global Marketing 4 days 46 days Free via subscription
Journal of Macromarketing 1 day 58 days Free via subscription
Journal of Marketing 4 days 59 days Free via subscription
Industrial Marketing Management 3 days 62 days Free via subscription
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing 3 days 63 days Free via subscription
Journal of International Marketing 4 days 69 days Free via subscription
International Journal of Research in Marketing 8 days 70 days Free via subscription
Journal of Marketing Research 5 days 75 days Free via subscription
Journal of Marketing Management 8 days 75 days Free via subscription
Journal of Consumer Psychology 16 days Not published Free via subscription

All hybrid journals above also offer paid open access. Figures are medians or averages reported by each publisher and change as new submissions come in, so check the journal page before you submit.

Writing for a fast marketing journal #

Make the fit obvious on page one #

Most of the speed in this list comes from editors who screen quickly. They read the title, the abstract and the first pages, and then decide whether reviewers should see the paper. Name the marketing problem in the first paragraph, say which conversation in the journal you are joining, and cite two or three recent papers from that same journal. A desk rejection in four days is useful information, but a paper that clearly belongs will skip that step.

Prepare the review package before you submit #

A short review round only helps if your own revisions are quick too. Keep your data, code, stimuli and survey instruments organized so you can rerun an analysis or add a sensitivity analysis within a week or two. For experiments, have pretests and manipulation checks ready to report. When the decision letter arrives, reply to every point in a response table and keep the tone plain and specific.

Plan a sequence of journals #

Students who publish quickly during a PhD usually have a ranked list of two or three journals for each paper. Start with the most ambitious outlet that fits, and if the paper comes back as a desk decision, revise the framing for the next journal within days. Keep the formatting light until the paper is accepted, since every journal on this list has its own reference style and word limit. Track your submission dates so you can compare your own wait times with the published figures.

See more of Marketingly in GoogleAdd us as a preferred source and our articles show up more in your Top Stories.

Keep reading

More guides.

Want help applying this?

Book a free consultation and we will look at your site together.